do you cost the whole pineapple or just the 650g you use? husband says I'm overthinking

Home Bakery Business costingpricingyieldbusiness

Costing my pineapple pastry properly for the first time and I've hit a philosophical dispute at home.

I buy a pineapple for ₹120. After peeling and coring I get maybe 650 grams of usable flesh. My recipe uses that 650g. I say the recipe cost includes the full ₹120, I had to buy the whole fruit to get my 650g. Husband says only the proportional cost of what physically went in.

Who is right? And the follow-up argument... he also says my four hours of baking are "free because you enjoy it", which, well. I need this forum to settle 😌

Want the version of this answer that comes with a kitchen?

Truffle Nation's professional programme runs at our Delhi (Saket) campus — hands-on, small batches, and built around actually earning from what you bake.

  • 4–6 month professional programme, Delhi campus
  • 1:8 chef-to-student ratio — real bench time, not demos
  • Full eggless curriculum alongside classic French technique
  • 400+ students placed and running their own bakeries
  • Business & pricing strategy built into the course

4 replies

You win both arguments :) The concept has a name - effective yield.

You paid ₹120 for 650g of usable ingredient. The peel and core were never available to sell. So your true price is 120 ÷ 0.65 ≈ ₹185 per usable kilo, and that's the rate your recipe consumes. Do this once for every trimmed ingredient - fruit, poached nuts, vegetables - and write each one's yield down. There's no universal number btw. Pineapple is around 60-65%, bananas 65-70, shelled skinned nuts can dip under 50.

Your four hours: not free, and this one matters more than the pineapple. Decide a fair monthly salary for your baking hours and put it into overheads next to electricity, gas, packaging. The business that skips this line has broken pricing the day it hires help... or the day you realise you bought yourself a job with no wages. Profit margin (25-30% is a sound band) goes on top of a costing that already pays you.

Add a small wastage line too, 5-10% while you're standardising. Every professional kitchen prices this way. We spend half a day on exactly this in the business module at our Delhi campus because pricing errors sink more home bakeries than baking errors do.

Show him this thread 😄

is there a standard yield % I can just slap on everything? 65 across the board?

Tempting but no - berries are nearly 100%, some nuts under 50. A flat number quietly misprices your most expensive ingredients, which is exactly where the money leaks. Good news is it's a one-time measurement per ingredient. Ten minutes of weighing covers your whole menu, keep a note on your phone.

screenshot of the salary paragraph has been forwarded to the household finance committee. case closed 😌 thank you!

Add your reply

Replies are reviewed by our team before they appear, to keep the community useful and spam-free.

Please enter your name.
Please write at least 20 characters.

Related discussions

does the costing method from indian home bakery guides translate abroad? pricing in dirhams now
Home Bakery Business · 13 Days Ago
scaling a recipe for big batches - is there proper maths or do I just multiply everything?
Home Bakery Business · 15 Days Ago
how do you honestly decide a best-before date without a food lab?
Home Bakery Business · 15 Days Ago
which preservative is actually safe for home bakers? amazon has 4 and zero sensible instructions
Home Bakery Business · 16 Days Ago
Browse all discussions →