how long should hand kneading take?? and is slap and fold legit

Baking & Technique kneadingtechniquebread

Twenty minutes into kneading yesterday, arms dying, dough still shaggy, wondering if I'm doing a completely wrong motion. How long should hand kneading actually take? And is the dramatic slap-and-fold thing people do on reels a real technique or content?

Want the version of this answer that comes with a kitchen?

Truffle Nation's professional programme runs at our Delhi (Saket) campus — hands-on, small batches, and built around actually earning from what you bake.

  • 4–6 month professional programme, Delhi campus
  • 1:8 chef-to-student ratio — real bench time, not demos
  • Full eggless curriculum alongside classic French technique
  • 400+ students placed and running their own bakeries
  • Business & pricing strategy built into the course

2 replies

10-15 minutes is the normal window for hand kneading, 20 at the outside - so if you're at twenty and still shaggy, the motion (or the dough) needs a look, not more suffering.

The course methods: stretch-and-combine - stretch the dough forward, fold it back, rotate, repeat with rhythm. And cross-kneading in fast 2-3 minute bursts. Both build gluten by stretching and layering it.

Slap-and-fold is completely legit, not just content - it develops gluten the same way and is especially good for wet sticky doughs that stretch-and-fold would leave glued to your palms. It just LOOKS dramatic.

Two common reasons for the never-ending knead: added fat too early (butter blocks gluten bonding, it goes in at 70-80% development), or sneaking in bench flour that keeps the dough permanently behind. Wet hands beat extra flour. And check with the windowpane at minute 12 rather than kneading to exhaustion - the dough often arrives before the arms admit it.

"the dough often arrives before the arms admit it" - checked at 12 min today and it was DONE. I've been overkneading out of insecurity for months

Add your reply

Replies are reviewed by our team before they appear, to keep the community useful and spam-free.

Please enter your name.
Please write at least 20 characters.

Related discussions

why do my loaves NEVER have that crackly crust? soft tops every single time
Baking & Technique · 12 Days Ago
machine kneading vs hand kneading - is one actually BETTER or just faster?
Baking & Technique · 13 Days Ago
what's the little slit cut into some pastries actually for?
Baking & Technique · 13 Days Ago
colouring chocolate for painted bonbons - my gel colours keep seizing everything!!
Baking & Technique · 13 Days Ago
Browse all discussions →